The Files, Case 16: A Decade of Shorting 88,000 Members — $41 Million

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 16. 414 words

Health Net of New Jersey underpaid its own members’ out-of-network claims for a decade — medical claims from 1996, dental, mental health and chiropractic claims from 1999. When the state caught the problem in 2002, Health Net said it ran only from July 2001 to October 2002. The state’s exam found otherwise.

The New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance first learned of it in 2002, from a consumer complaint. That December it settled with Health Net for more than $800,000 in restitution to more than 4,700 members. In 2005, the Department learned the underpayments had begun earlier than Health Net had disclosed. A 21-month examination followed, concluding in May 2008.

The findings, in the Department’s own words: Health Net “systemically under-reimbursed certain types of claims,” affecting approximately 88,000 members; “failed to initially disclose to the Department the true extent of under-reimbursements”; “failed to initially properly remediate under-reimbursements”; and “improperly denied certain claims for lack of pre-authorization.” The company’s vendors for chiropractic and mental health services made underpayments too.

The order: $14 million in unpaid claims, $12 million in interest, $2 million in examination fees, and a record $13 million fine — $41 million in all. The $26 million in restitution and interest had already been paid to the 88,000 members. Commissioner Steven M. Goldman put it plainly: “Health Net dramatically underpaid claims to New Jerseyans to reimburse them for out-of-network health care services.” Health Net waived its right to a hearing, acknowledged its responsibility to comply with the law, and overhauled the systems that led to the underpayments. The Department said it would keep monitoring the company.

Outcome: Settled (consent order). New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance, Consent Order No. E08-71, August 26, 2008: Health Net of New Jersey paid $14 million in unpaid claims, $12 million in interest, $2 million in examination fees, and a record $13 million fine — $41 million in total — and had already paid $26 million in restitution and interest to approximately 88,000 members. Health Net waived its right to a hearing and cooperated with the investigation.

Source: New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance press release, August 26, 2008 — read the release. DOBI 2008 enforcement activity listing, Consent Order No. E08-71 — read the listing.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 15: 1,600 Policies Cancelled — $35.5 Million Saved

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 15. 611 words

Health Net of California cancelled about 1,600 individual health policies between 2000 and 2006 — after the policyholders got sick and the bills started arriving. The company’s own documents, produced at an arbitration hearing, showed it avoided $35.5 million in medical expenses by doing it. The practice has a name: rescission. Sell the policy, collect the premiums, and cancel it when the claim comes in.

The documents showed why it kept happening. Health Net set cancellation targets and paid bonuses tied in part to how many policies its senior analyst revoked. In 2002, her goal was 180 cancellations. She cancelled 275. She received more than $20,000 in bonuses based in part on meeting or exceeding those targets. California law forbids tying a claims reviewer’s pay to claims decisions. Health Net’s lawyer argued the law did not apply — she was an underwriter, not a claims reviewer.

Patsy Bates, a 51-year-old hair salon owner from Gardena, had her coverage rescinded while she was receiving chemotherapy for breast cancer. She was left with $129,000 in medical bills and had to stop her chemotherapy until a charity helped her pay. In February 2008, arbitrator Sam Cianchetti — a retired Los Angeles County Superior Court judge — awarded her more than $9 million, $8.4 million of it punitive. He called Health Net’s conduct “egregious” and wrote that the company “was primarily concerned with and considered its own financial interests and gave little, if any, consideration and concern for the interests of the insured.” On the bonuses, he wrote: “It’s difficult to imagine a policy more reprehensible than tying bonuses to encourage the rescission of health insurance that keeps the public well and alive.”

The regulators came next. In June 2008, the Department of Managed Health Care settled: a $300,000 fine and coverage offered to 85 HMO members. In September 2008, the California Department of Insurance settled: a $3.6 million fine, about $14.2 million in medical bills, and 926 policyholders reinstated — new policies with no underwriting requirement and no exclusions for preexisting conditions. Health Net admitted no wrongdoing in either settlement, but agreed to change its business practices.

In February 2009, the Los Angeles City Attorney’s class action settled too: up to $14 million to 800 former policyholders whose coverage was dropped after they submitted substantial medical bills — up to $218,000 each — plus a $2 million fine to the city attorney and $500,000 to charities. All told, Health Net agreed to pay more than $40 million across the regulatory actions and the litigation. The $35.5 million it saved by cancelling 1,600 sick people’s policies was the math that made the whole thing work — until the receipts came out.

Outcome: Settled (regulatory settlements + class action). June 2008: Health Net settled with the California Department of Managed Health Care — a $300,000 fine and coverage offered to 85 HMO members. September 2008: Health Net settled with the California Department of Insurance — a $3.6 million fine, about $14.2 million in medical bills, and 926 policyholders reinstated. February 2009: the Los Angeles City Attorney class action settled — up to $14 million to 800 former policyholders (up to $218,000 each), a $2 million fine, and $500,000 in charitable contributions. More than $40 million in total. Health Net did not admit wrongdoing.

Source: California Department of Insurance–Health Net settlement, September 2008 — read the report. Los Angeles City Attorney settlement, February 2009 — read the report.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 14: Dropping the Sick — $25 Million

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 14. 512 words

Between January 2004 and July 2008, Anthem Blue Cross cancelled the individual health coverage of 1,773 Californians. The cancellations came after the patients got sick and the bills started arriving. The practice has a name — postclaims underwriting — and California law bans it. The state’s Department of Managed Health Care put the number in writing: 1,773 rescinded memberships out of about 294,000 people enrolled.

The department’s own probe had found all 90 rescissions it sampled were flawed. Anthem had sold the policies, collected the premiums, and then — after the diagnosis, after the claim — gone back through the application looking for a reason to cancel. The department’s director had told the Associated Press the state failed to pursue a $1 million fine against Anthem because it was intimidated by the company’s legal prowess. Days later, the state vowed to seek penalties that could have totaled $354 million.

The settlement, effective July 18, 2008, put numbers on it. Anthem paid a $10 million administrative fine — the largest the department had ever collected — and agreed not to rescind any individual or family policy issued on or before that date. The 1,770 former members still unresolved were offered coverage again, with no medical underwriting, and reimbursement of the medical bills they had paid out of pocket after being dropped.

Seven months later, the second regulator closed the other half. The California Department of Insurance, which oversees PPO policies, settled on February 11, 2009: a $1 million fine, coverage offered to 2,330 more people whose PPO policies had been rescinded, and an estimated $14 million in reimbursements for medical expenses they paid after being dropped. In exchange, the state dropped its prosecution of the accusation that Anthem broke the law in how it rescinded PPO members between 2004 and 2008.

Anthem admitted no wrongdoing in either settlement. The agreements say so plainly. But the remedy is on the record: about $25 million in fines and reimbursements, more than 4,000 people offered their coverage back, and a line drawn — no more rescissions of policies issued before July 18, 2008. The receipts are the two settlement agreements themselves.

Outcome: Settled (two regulatory settlements). July 18, 2008: Anthem Blue Cross settled with the California Department of Managed Health Care — a $10 million administrative fine, no rescission of any individual or family policy issued on or before that date, coverage offered without medical underwriting to 1,770 former members, and reimbursement of out-of-pocket medical expenses. February 11, 2009: Anthem settled with the California Department of Insurance — a $1 million fine, coverage offered to 2,330 PPO members, and an estimated $14 million in reimbursements. Anthem did not admit wrongdoing in either settlement.

Source: DMHC–Anthem Blue Cross Settlement Agreement, July 18, 2008 — read the agreement. California Department of Insurance settlement, February 11, 2009 — read the report.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 13: The $77 Million Disability Reassessment

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 13. 476 words

In May 2013, five states settled with Cigna. California, Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, and Pennsylvania had spent years examining how three Cigna companies — Cigna Health and Life, Connecticut General Life, and the Life Insurance Company of North America — handled group long-term disability claims. The examinations began in 2009. What they found, in the words of Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner Michael Consedine, was that the companies “were lax and not using available information to appropriately process disability income insurance claims.”

“Not using available information” is the polite version. These were disability claims — people too sick or hurt to work, asking the insurer to pay what the policy promised. The regulators found the companies deciding those claims without using the information in front of them. California had been here before: it fined LINA $600,000 in 2006 over disability claims-handling violations, and reopened that examination as part of this one.

The settlement, signed May 13, 2013, put numbers on it. The companies paid $1,675,000 in fines and fees to the five states — $500,000 to California, $250,000 to Massachusetts, $175,000 to Maine — and set aside $77 million for the policyholders: $48 million in reserves in case additional benefits were owed, and $29 million more for claims still open. They had to re-examine every long-term disability claim denied or terminated in 2009 and 2010 — in California, back to 2008 — under new procedures, and submit to two years of monitoring by the five states, with a re-examination at the end.

Cigna denied wrongdoing. This was not a jury verdict; it was a regulatory settlement built on the states’ examination findings. But the remedy tells the story: $77 million put aside for people whose claims were not handled properly, thousands of denied claims reopened, and new procedures the companies had to adopt — giving greater weight to Social Security disability approvals, and taking every reasonable step to verify a claimant’s condition. The kind of steps the examination found missing.

Five states. One examination finding. Seventy-seven million dollars. The receipts are the settlement agreement itself — signed, filed, and paid.

Outcome: Settled (regulatory settlement agreement). On May 13, 2013, Cigna Health and Life Insurance Company, Connecticut General Life Insurance Company, and the Life Insurance Company of North America settled with the insurance departments of California, Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, and Pennsylvania. The companies paid $1,675,000 in fines and fees and set aside $77 million for payments to policyholders whose claims were not handled properly. The companies denied wrongdoing.

Source: California Department of Insurance press release, May 24, 2013 — read the announcement. Regulatory Settlement Agreement, May 13, 2013 — read the agreement.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 12: The Case That Created Bad-Faith Law

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 12. 681 words

In 1962, Michael Egan, a roofer, bought a health and disability policy from Mutual of Omaha. It promised $200 a month for life if he became totally disabled by an accidental injury. Between 1963 and 1970 he claimed and received benefits for three separate back injuries. In May 1970, working as a roofer, he hurt his back again — a fourth claim, for an accidental injury on the job.

Mutual paid three months of accident benefits. Then its adjusters went to work. They reviewed workers’ compensation records and hospital files. They read letters from Egan’s surgeon, who said his history was “consistent with a man with probable discogenic disease with multiple aggravations over the last several years, finally culminating in a specific incident a little over seven months ago.” They never called Egan’s doctors. Trial testimony established that an adjuster would ordinarily have done so.

On the basis of the paper alone, Mutual reclassified Egan’s injury as a sickness — a nonconfining illness, capped at three months of benefits. In May 1971, an adjuster visited Egan at home, told him he suffered from an illness, not an injury, and handed him a check for medical costs and three months’ maximum disability payments. Egan did not cash it. He testified the adjuster offered him a larger check if he would surrender his policy. He refused. He wrote to the adjuster about the reclassification and got no answer. Meanwhile his file, a Mutual manager testified, may have “fallen … into a crack.” In July 1972, at Egan’s request, the California Department of Insurance asked Mutual to review the file. Whatever Mutual answered was never produced at trial.

Egan sued in 1973. The trial court ruled as a matter of law that Mutual’s failure to have Egan examined by a doctor of its choice, or to consult his treating physicians, violated the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The jury awarded $45,600 in general damages and $78,000 for emotional distress against Mutual — and $5 million in punitive damages.

On August 14, 1979, the California Supreme Court affirmed the compensatory award and the breach. An insurer, the court held, “cannot reasonably and in good faith deny payments to its insured without thoroughly investigating the foundation for its denial.” It is “essential that an insurer fully inquire into possible bases that might support the insured’s claim.” That sentence is the foundation of modern bad-faith law: the duty to investigate before denying.

But the court cut the $5 million punitive award — more than 40 times the $123,600 in compensatory damages, and two and a half months of Mutual’s entire 1973 net income. Viewing the record as a whole, the court said, the award “must be deemed the result of passion and prejudice on the part of the jurors and excessive as a matter of law.” It also reversed the judgments against the two individual adjusters: as agents, they were not parties to the insurance contract and were not subject to the implied covenant. Egan kept his $123,600. The $5 million was gone.

A roofer who hurt his back on the job. An insurer that read the paper, never called the doctors, and called an injury a sickness. The court that said investigate first — and that even a company that breaks faith does not owe $5 million for it. That is the case that created bad-faith law, caveat included.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. The California Supreme Court, 24 Cal.3d 809 (Aug. 14, 1979), affirmed the jury’s finding that Mutual of Omaha breached the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and affirmed the $45,600 in disability benefits and $78,000 for emotional distress. It reversed the $5 million punitive award as excessive and reversed the judgments against the two individual adjusters.

Source: Egan v. Mutual of Omaha Ins. Co., 24 Cal.3d 809 (1979) — read the opinion.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 11: The $100,000 Policy That Became a $9.2 Million Judgment

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 11. 686 words

On August 8, 2006, James Harvey’s car collided with John Potts’s car. Potts, 51, died. He left a wife and three children. Harvey was 100% at fault. Harvey’s GEICO policy had $100,000 in liability limits. The estate’s wrongful-death case ended with an $8.47 million jury verdict against Harvey — nearly 85 times his policy limits.

GEICO knew within two days that Harvey was at fault and that the claim would blow past his limits. On August 11, adjuster Fran Korkus wrote Harvey that the claim could exceed his policy limits and that he could hire his own lawyer. Three days later, a paralegal for the estate’s lawyer called Korkus and asked for a recorded statement from Harvey — to find out what assets he had, whether he had other insurance, whether he had been on the job. Korkus did not pass the request to Harvey. The paralegal said Korkus denied it.

Nine days after the crash, GEICO sent the estate’s lawyer the full $100,000, with a release and an affidavit of coverage. The money was there. The information was not. The estate’s lawyer wrote back, acknowledging the check — and Korkus’s refusal to make Harvey available for a statement. Korkus received the letter on August 31 and faxed it to Harvey. It was the first Harvey had heard that a statement had been requested.

The next day, Harvey called Korkus himself. He said he would meet with his own lawyer to go over his financial documents and give the estate what it asked for. His lawyer was not available until September 5. Harvey asked Korkus to tell the estate’s lawyer they were working on it. Korkus’s supervisor told her to pass the message along. She did not. On September 13 — a month after the statement was first requested — the estate sent the $100,000 check back and filed suit.

At the bad-faith trial, the estate’s lawyer testified he had heard nothing from GEICO after his August 31 letter. He testified that if he had known Harvey’s only other asset was a business account worth about $85,000, he would never have filed suit — he would have told the widow to take the $100,000. Korkus herself conceded the request was reasonable. GEICO’s own expert agreed the estate’s lawyer needed the information to advise his client. The widow testified she would have taken the limits if her lawyer had told her to. Korkus, the court record shows, was handling about 130 claims at the time, and her personnel file recorded trouble managing her files and communicating.

The jury found GEICO acted in bad faith. The trial court entered a $9.2 million judgment. The Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed, ruling the evidence was insufficient as a matter of law — and that even if GEICO’s conduct had been deficient, it had not caused the excess judgment. On September 20, 2018, the Florida Supreme Court, 4-3, quashed that decision and ordered the $9.2 million judgment reinstated. Tendering the policy limits, the court said, does not end an insurer’s obligations. GEICO, the court wrote, “completely dropped the ball” — it had failed to act as if Harvey’s financial exposure was a “ticking financial time bomb.”

A $100,000 policy. The money was tendered in nine days. The statement the estate needed was never delivered. The Florida Supreme Court put the $9.2 million judgment back on the books.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. A jury found GEICO General Insurance Company acted in bad faith in failing to settle the Potts estate’s claim within James Harvey’s $100,000 policy limits; the trial court entered judgment for $9.2 million. The Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed, but the Florida Supreme Court, 4-3, quashed that decision on September 20, 2018 (No. SC17-85) and remanded for reinstatement of the final judgment.

Source: Harvey v. GEICO General Insurance Co., No. SC17-85 (Fla. Sept. 20, 2018) — read the opinion.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 10: The Wrong Zip Code

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 10. 726 words

On March 29, 1990, Marion Taylor’s car collided with a car owned by Barry Berges. The crash killed Marion Taylor and seriously injured her young daughter, who was riding with her. Infinity Insurance Company insured Berges’s car. The policy limits were $10,000 per person and $20,000 per accident. By April 30, Infinity’s own investigator had concluded that the driver of Berges’s car had been intoxicated, had crossed the center line, and was “100%” at fault. The daughter’s medical bills were already over $30,000.

On May 2, the widower walked into Infinity’s office and hand-delivered a letter. He offered to settle both claims for the $20,000 limits: his wife’s wrongful-death claim for $10,000, his daughter’s injury claim for $10,000. He needed the money paid by May 27 for the estate and by June 1 for his daughter. He had missed a great deal of work. Doctor bills were coming almost every day. His daughter was hurt very bad, and he expected many more bills, especially because she had scarring from the surgery. He stapled some of the bills to the letter.

Infinity never told Berges the offer existed. On May 11, adjuster Robert Fryer called Taylor and said Infinity would pay the limits and arrange the court approval the minor’s claim needed. Fryer said he would meet with Infinity’s attorney on May 14 to work out the details. The meeting never happened. Fryer never told Taylor. On May 16, Infinity hired attorney Kevin Korth to seek the court’s approval. Korth’s own May 23 memorandum said Infinity was operating under a “time demand.” Korth finally wrote to Taylor on May 24 — thirteen days after Fryer’s promise, three days before the first deadline.

The letter used the wrong zip code. It did not reach Taylor until June 20, after both deadlines had expired. Taylor had heard nothing from Infinity since May 11. On June 11, his lawyer wrote Infinity that the May 2 offer was revoked. The wrongful-death and personal-injury suits followed. The jury awarded $911,400 for Marion Taylor’s death and $500,000 for her daughter’s injuries. Berges, who had bought a $20,000 policy, now faced a judgment nearly a hundred times that.

Almost a month after the deadlines expired, Infinity told Berges — for the first time — that he faced an excess judgment and could hire his own lawyer. The letter’s postscript said Taylor “refused to settle.” It did not mention the deadlines. It did not mention the terms of the offer. It did not mention that Infinity had never told Berges the offer existed.

Berges sued Infinity for bad faith. A jury found Infinity acted in bad faith in failing to settle the Taylor claims within the limits and in failing to advise its insured about the offer. The trial court entered an amended final judgment of $1,893,066.41 — the excess judgment plus accrued interest. The Second District Court of Appeal reversed, saying the offer was invalid because Taylor had not obtained court approval first. On November 18, 2004, the Florida Supreme Court quashed that decision and ordered the judgment reinstated, holding the jury’s bad-faith finding “was supported by competent, substantial evidence.” Court approval, the court said, is not a prerequisite to a valid settlement offer for a minor.

A $20,000 policy. A handwritten offer, delivered by hand. A promise on the phone, a meeting that never happened, a letter sent to the wrong zip code. The Florida Supreme Court put the $1,893,066.41 judgment back on the books.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. A jury found Infinity Insurance Company acted in bad faith toward its insured, Barry Berges, in failing to settle the Taylor claims within the $20,000 policy limits and in failing to advise Berges of the settlement offer; the trial court entered an amended final judgment of $1,893,066.41. The Second District Court of Appeal reversed, but the Florida Supreme Court quashed that decision on November 18, 2004 (896 So. 2d 665) and remanded for reinstatement of the final judgment, holding the bad-faith finding “was supported by competent, substantial evidence.”

Source: Berges v. Infinity Insurance Co., 896 So. 2d 665 (Fla. 2004) — read the opinion.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 9: The Biased Medical Examiner

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 9. 679 words

Joan Hangarter ran her own chiropractic practice in Berkeley, California, treating 30 to 50 patients a day. In 1989 she bought an “own occupation” disability policy from the Paul Revere Life Insurance Company. If she could no longer do her own job, the policy would pay. By 1997, shoulder, elbow, and wrist pain had left her unable to work. She filed a claim. Paul Revere paid her for eleven months. Then it stopped.

The decision rested on one doctor. Paul Revere hired Dr. Aubrey Swartz as its “independent medical examiner.” The company had used Dr. Swartz nineteen times from 1995 to 2000. In thirteen out of thirteen total-disability cases, he rejected the claim. Before he ever examined Hangarter, an in-house medical consultant who had never examined her either wrote him that there were no objective findings of a disabling injury. At trial, an industry expert testified that letter “bias[ed]” and “predispos[ed]” the doctor. Dr. Swartz called her condition “normal” and said she could see two patients an hour. Her own doctors disagreed: three MRIs showed her condition worsening, and they testified she could not maintain a normal, continuous chiropractic occupation. While a hired colleague covered her practice, Hangarter performed adjustments for only 5 of more than 9,000 patient visits. She sold the practice because she could no longer afford to pay her replacement.

The letter that cut her off was, in the words of the expert who testified at trial, misleading, deceptive, and below industry standards. It said she was “working,” and therefore ineligible — false, because she had already sold her practice. It then denied her residual benefits on the opposite ground: because she had sold her business and “was not working.” It said nothing about recovery or rehabilitation benefits, which she had asked about and been wrongly told she could not have. And it told her the policy was governed by ERISA — which, if true, would have cut off her state-law remedies, including punitive damages. After the termination, the company attached her bank account for insurance premiums until the account was drained, and then cancelled her policy.

The trial showed the machinery behind the letter. Paul Revere had a system for targeting expensive claims — “own occupation” policies held by disabled professionals who had been receiving benefits for months or years — and ran “round table” claim reviews with the goal of achieving a “net termination ratio”: the value of terminated claims compared with new ones. After eleven days of trial, a unanimous jury awarded Hangarter $7,670,849: $5,000,000 in punitive damages, $1,520,849 in past and future unpaid benefits, $400,000 for emotional distress, and $750,000 in attorneys’ fees. On June 25, 2004, the Ninth Circuit affirmed. It held that UnumProvident — Paul Revere’s parent — “engaged in biased and bad faith claims handling and investigation,” and that her own treating physician “was misled by defendant’s systematic claims practices.” The court reversed only a permanent injunction the trial judge had issued under California’s Unfair Competition Act.

An examiner used nineteen times, who rejected the claim thirteen times out of thirteen. A termination letter that said she was working and not working on the same page. A bank account drained for premiums, then a cancelled policy. The jury put a $7,670,849 number on it. A federal appeals court kept it.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. After eleven days of trial, a unanimous federal jury in San Francisco awarded Joan Hangarter $7,670,849 — $5,000,000 punitive damages, $1,520,849 past and future unpaid benefits, $400,000 emotional distress, $750,000 attorneys’ fees (N.D. Cal.). The Ninth Circuit affirmed the denial of judgment as a matter of law and the damages award on June 25, 2004 (373 F.3d 998), reversing only a permanent injunction issued under California’s Unfair Competition Act.

Source: Hangarter v. Provident Life & Accident Insurance Co., 373 F.3d 998 (9th Cir. 2004) — read the opinion.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 8: The First Big Unum Loss

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 8. 434 words

Dr. John Tedesco was an eye surgeon in Florida. In 1992 he bought a disability policy from the Paul Revere Life Insurance Company — about $3,800 a year. The promise was simple: if he could no longer operate, he would still be paid. He paid his premiums. Then Parkinson’s disease and a herniated back left him with hand tremors. He could no longer hold a scalpel steady. In early 1998 he closed his practice.

Paul Revere paid him for five months. Then it stopped. Tedesco sued. The case went to trial in Tampa — nine days of evidence in federal court. Three months before trial, the company paid $265,000 in back benefits. The jury was not persuaded. On May 25, 2001, it found the company had fraudulently terminated his disability benefits and awarded $36.7 million in punitive damages.

The verdict made news. CBS’s “60 Minutes” featured the case, and the trial record became the evidence trove for the Unum cases that followed. But the verdict did not stand as a judgment. Paul Revere moved for a new trial. The two sides went to mediation in March 2002, and the mediator reported the case had been “completely settled.” On the parties’ joint motion, the judge vacated the verdict and the judgment and dismissed the case with prejudice. The settlement amount was never disclosed.

A surgeon who could not hold a scalpel steady bought a policy that promised to pay him if that day came. The company paid for five months, then cut him off. A jury called it fraud and put a $36.7 million number on it. Then the parties settled, the verdict was vacated, and the number went away. The record of what the jury found is still there.

Outcome: Plaintiff won at trial, then settled. A federal jury in Tampa awarded Dr. John Tedesco $36.7 million in punitive damages on May 25, 2001 (M.D. Fla., No. 8:99-cv-2552), finding Paul Revere Life Insurance Company fraudulently terminated his disability benefits. In March 2002 the parties settled; on May 3, 2002, the court vacated the verdict and judgment and dismissed the case with prejudice on the parties’ joint motion. The settlement amount was not disclosed.

Source: Tedesco v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., No. 8:99-cv-2552 (M.D. Fla.) — read the docket. Plaintiff Magazine’s account of the Unum cases — read it.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 7: The Termination Targets

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 7. 542 words

Dr. Randall Chapman was an eye surgeon in Novato, California. For 20 years he performed eye surgery. In 1983 he bought a disability policy from Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company. In 1987 he bought another from The Paul Revere Life Insurance Company — and with it came a “specialty letter,” a written promise that he was insured in his particular specialty as an eye surgeon. He paid his premiums every month for 17 years.

In the late 1990s, Chapman started to develop extreme anxiety about surgery — panic attacks, shaking hands, diarrhea, vomiting, sleepless nights. Surgeries began to go wrong. He took himself off the surgery schedule. His psychiatrist diagnosed a specific phobia — panic in the operating room — and told him to retire from eye surgery. He filed his disability claim.

At trial, which lasted three months, the jury heard how the claim was handled. The claims department read his medical records in a way calculated to produce a denial. The company held a secret “roundtable” meeting about his claim — and destroyed the notes, company policy. It never had him examined by an unbiased physician. It said his condition could be treated, said he was not even an eye surgeon, called him a fraud — and denied his claim to meet monthly and quarterly termination goals. Management called the expected savings reserve “recoveries” — dollar amounts of claims it expected to terminate in the coming months, distributed as targets inside the claims department.

The jury found Chapman totally disabled from his occupation and entitled to disability benefits for the rest of his life: $1,551,301 in benefits, $125,000 for emotional distress, and $30 million in punitive damages. The $31.7 million verdict was the largest in Marin County history — by a factor of three. It was the second-largest verdict in the nation in a UnumProvident case.

Then the trial judge cut it. She reduced the benefits to $1,112,405, the emotional distress to $15,000, and the punitive damages to $5 million. Chapman’s lawyers objected and appealed the reduction. UnumProvident appealed the bad-faith and punitive findings. The verdict came as regulators in California, Georgia and Tennessee were examining the company’s claims practices.

A surgeon paid for 17 years for a promise: if he could no longer operate, he was covered. When his hands shook too much to hold a scalpel, the company called him a fraud. The trial showed the denial was not a judgment call. It was a termination goal.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. Marin County Superior Court, Jan. 23, 2003: a jury awarded Dr. Randall Chapman $31.7 million — $1,551,301 in lifetime disability benefits, $125,000 emotional distress, $30 million punitive damages — finding UnumProvident acted with malice and fraud and denied his claim in bad faith. The trial judge reduced the award to $6.1 million ($1,112,405 benefits, $15,000 emotional distress, $5 million punitive). Both sides appealed.

Source: Chapman v. UnumProvident Corp., No. CV-012323 (Cal. Super. Ct., Marin Co., Jan. 23, 2003) — read the verdict account. The Wall Street Journal’s report, via PLANSPONSOR — read it.

More from The Files →