The Files, Case 8: The First Big Unum Loss

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 8. 434 words

Dr. John Tedesco was an eye surgeon in Florida. In 1992 he bought a disability policy from the Paul Revere Life Insurance Company — about $3,800 a year. The promise was simple: if he could no longer operate, he would still be paid. He paid his premiums. Then Parkinson’s disease and a herniated back left him with hand tremors. He could no longer hold a scalpel steady. In early 1998 he closed his practice.

Paul Revere paid him for five months. Then it stopped. Tedesco sued. The case went to trial in Tampa — nine days of evidence in federal court. Three months before trial, the company paid $265,000 in back benefits. The jury was not persuaded. On May 25, 2001, it found the company had fraudulently terminated his disability benefits and awarded $36.7 million in punitive damages.

The verdict made news. CBS’s “60 Minutes” featured the case, and the trial record became the evidence trove for the Unum cases that followed. But the verdict did not stand as a judgment. Paul Revere moved for a new trial. The two sides went to mediation in March 2002, and the mediator reported the case had been “completely settled.” On the parties’ joint motion, the judge vacated the verdict and the judgment and dismissed the case with prejudice. The settlement amount was never disclosed.

A surgeon who could not hold a scalpel steady bought a policy that promised to pay him if that day came. The company paid for five months, then cut him off. A jury called it fraud and put a $36.7 million number on it. Then the parties settled, the verdict was vacated, and the number went away. The record of what the jury found is still there.

Outcome: Plaintiff won at trial, then settled. A federal jury in Tampa awarded Dr. John Tedesco $36.7 million in punitive damages on May 25, 2001 (M.D. Fla., No. 8:99-cv-2552), finding Paul Revere Life Insurance Company fraudulently terminated his disability benefits. In March 2002 the parties settled; on May 3, 2002, the court vacated the verdict and judgment and dismissed the case with prejudice on the parties’ joint motion. The settlement amount was not disclosed.

Source: Tedesco v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., No. 8:99-cv-2552 (M.D. Fla.) — read the docket. Plaintiff Magazine’s account of the Unum cases — read it.

More from The Files →

Leave a Reply