The Files, Case 11: The $100,000 Policy That Became a $9.2 Million Judgment

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 11. 686 words

On August 8, 2006, James Harvey’s car collided with John Potts’s car. Potts, 51, died. He left a wife and three children. Harvey was 100% at fault. Harvey’s GEICO policy had $100,000 in liability limits. The estate’s wrongful-death case ended with an $8.47 million jury verdict against Harvey — nearly 85 times his policy limits.

GEICO knew within two days that Harvey was at fault and that the claim would blow past his limits. On August 11, adjuster Fran Korkus wrote Harvey that the claim could exceed his policy limits and that he could hire his own lawyer. Three days later, a paralegal for the estate’s lawyer called Korkus and asked for a recorded statement from Harvey — to find out what assets he had, whether he had other insurance, whether he had been on the job. Korkus did not pass the request to Harvey. The paralegal said Korkus denied it.

Nine days after the crash, GEICO sent the estate’s lawyer the full $100,000, with a release and an affidavit of coverage. The money was there. The information was not. The estate’s lawyer wrote back, acknowledging the check — and Korkus’s refusal to make Harvey available for a statement. Korkus received the letter on August 31 and faxed it to Harvey. It was the first Harvey had heard that a statement had been requested.

The next day, Harvey called Korkus himself. He said he would meet with his own lawyer to go over his financial documents and give the estate what it asked for. His lawyer was not available until September 5. Harvey asked Korkus to tell the estate’s lawyer they were working on it. Korkus’s supervisor told her to pass the message along. She did not. On September 13 — a month after the statement was first requested — the estate sent the $100,000 check back and filed suit.

At the bad-faith trial, the estate’s lawyer testified he had heard nothing from GEICO after his August 31 letter. He testified that if he had known Harvey’s only other asset was a business account worth about $85,000, he would never have filed suit — he would have told the widow to take the $100,000. Korkus herself conceded the request was reasonable. GEICO’s own expert agreed the estate’s lawyer needed the information to advise his client. The widow testified she would have taken the limits if her lawyer had told her to. Korkus, the court record shows, was handling about 130 claims at the time, and her personnel file recorded trouble managing her files and communicating.

The jury found GEICO acted in bad faith. The trial court entered a $9.2 million judgment. The Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed, ruling the evidence was insufficient as a matter of law — and that even if GEICO’s conduct had been deficient, it had not caused the excess judgment. On September 20, 2018, the Florida Supreme Court, 4-3, quashed that decision and ordered the $9.2 million judgment reinstated. Tendering the policy limits, the court said, does not end an insurer’s obligations. GEICO, the court wrote, “completely dropped the ball” — it had failed to act as if Harvey’s financial exposure was a “ticking financial time bomb.”

A $100,000 policy. The money was tendered in nine days. The statement the estate needed was never delivered. The Florida Supreme Court put the $9.2 million judgment back on the books.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. A jury found GEICO General Insurance Company acted in bad faith in failing to settle the Potts estate’s claim within James Harvey’s $100,000 policy limits; the trial court entered judgment for $9.2 million. The Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed, but the Florida Supreme Court, 4-3, quashed that decision on September 20, 2018 (No. SC17-85) and remanded for reinstatement of the final judgment.

Source: Harvey v. GEICO General Insurance Co., No. SC17-85 (Fla. Sept. 20, 2018) — read the opinion.

More from The Files →

Leave a Reply