The Files, Case 14: Dropping the Sick — $25 Million

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 14. 512 words

Between January 2004 and July 2008, Anthem Blue Cross cancelled the individual health coverage of 1,773 Californians. The cancellations came after the patients got sick and the bills started arriving. The practice has a name — postclaims underwriting — and California law bans it. The state’s Department of Managed Health Care put the number in writing: 1,773 rescinded memberships out of about 294,000 people enrolled.

The department’s own probe had found all 90 rescissions it sampled were flawed. Anthem had sold the policies, collected the premiums, and then — after the diagnosis, after the claim — gone back through the application looking for a reason to cancel. The department’s director had told the Associated Press the state failed to pursue a $1 million fine against Anthem because it was intimidated by the company’s legal prowess. Days later, the state vowed to seek penalties that could have totaled $354 million.

The settlement, effective July 18, 2008, put numbers on it. Anthem paid a $10 million administrative fine — the largest the department had ever collected — and agreed not to rescind any individual or family policy issued on or before that date. The 1,770 former members still unresolved were offered coverage again, with no medical underwriting, and reimbursement of the medical bills they had paid out of pocket after being dropped.

Seven months later, the second regulator closed the other half. The California Department of Insurance, which oversees PPO policies, settled on February 11, 2009: a $1 million fine, coverage offered to 2,330 more people whose PPO policies had been rescinded, and an estimated $14 million in reimbursements for medical expenses they paid after being dropped. In exchange, the state dropped its prosecution of the accusation that Anthem broke the law in how it rescinded PPO members between 2004 and 2008.

Anthem admitted no wrongdoing in either settlement. The agreements say so plainly. But the remedy is on the record: about $25 million in fines and reimbursements, more than 4,000 people offered their coverage back, and a line drawn — no more rescissions of policies issued before July 18, 2008. The receipts are the two settlement agreements themselves.

Outcome: Settled (two regulatory settlements). July 18, 2008: Anthem Blue Cross settled with the California Department of Managed Health Care — a $10 million administrative fine, no rescission of any individual or family policy issued on or before that date, coverage offered without medical underwriting to 1,770 former members, and reimbursement of out-of-pocket medical expenses. February 11, 2009: Anthem settled with the California Department of Insurance — a $1 million fine, coverage offered to 2,330 PPO members, and an estimated $14 million in reimbursements. Anthem did not admit wrongdoing in either settlement.

Source: DMHC–Anthem Blue Cross Settlement Agreement, July 18, 2008 — read the agreement. California Department of Insurance settlement, February 11, 2009 — read the report.

More from The Files →

Leave a Reply