The Files, Case 6: The $60 Million Disability Retrial

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 6. 645 words

G. Clinton Merrick Jr. was a venture capitalist. In 1989 he bought an “own occupation” disability policy from Paul Revere Life Insurance Company — $12,000 a month if he could no longer do his job. In the early 1990s he got sick: fatigue, muscle pain, mental confusion. His doctors said chronic fatigue syndrome and Lyme disease. The Mayo Clinic agreed.

Paul Revere paid his claim from December 1994. Then it stopped. The examiner the company hired could not say whether Merrick could work, and the company’s own file said the records supported “significant impairment.” On December 9, 1996, Paul Revere denied the claim anyway — no “objective medical documentation,” it said, of an inability to work as a venture capitalist.

There was a problem with that demand. There is no objective test for chronic fatigue syndrome. Unum’s own internal studies said so, and the policy never required objective proof. The court later found the company knew all of it — and demanded the proof anyway.

At trial in 2004, the jury heard what the denial was part of. An insurance expert walked through the internal memos: pressure claimants to settle for a fraction, demand objective evidence the policy never required, build a stable of medical examiners who would support denials, have in-house doctors cherry-pick the file for reasons to deny, hold round-table meetings to triage the most expensive claims. The jury awarded Merrick $1,147,355 in unpaid benefits and $500,000 for emotional distress — and $10 million in punitive damages.

The Ninth Circuit threw out the punitive award in 2007 — not because the conduct was excused, but because the jury had not been given a required limiting instruction. It ordered a retrial on punitive damages only. In June 2008, the second jury came back with $60 million: $24 million against Paul Revere, $36 million against UnumProvident.

Then the trial judge put the findings in writing. In Merrick v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., 594 F. Supp. 2d 1168, the court found “more than ample evidence” that the companies were “engaged in a scheme to deny their disabled policyholders’ claims dating back to the early 1990s.” The conduct was “not the result of accident or inadvertence,” the court wrote, but “part of a widespread corporate plan or scheme designed to augment corporate profits through wrongful conduct targeted at disabled policyholders.” The court found the terminations were saving the companies over $130 million a quarter by 1996. It let the $24 million award stand and cut UnumProvident’s $36 million to $26,394,765.39 — a 9-to-1 ratio. The case settled in 2010.

A man bought a policy that promised to pay if he could not do his job. He could not do his job. The company had the paper that said so. It denied him anyway — and the paper trail showed it was not a mistake. It was the plan.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. 2004 jury: $1,147,355 in unpaid benefits, $500,000 emotional distress, $10 million punitive damages. The Ninth Circuit (500 F.3d 1007, 2007) ordered a retrial on punitive damages only. June 2008 retrial jury: $60 million punitive ($24 million Paul Revere, $36 million UnumProvident); the court let the $24 million stand and cut UnumProvident’s share to $26,394,765.39. Settled out of court, 2010.

Source: Merrick v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., 500 F.3d 1007 (9th Cir. 2007) — read the opinion. Judgment, July 3, 2008 ($24 million Paul Revere, $36 million UnumProvident) — read the judgment. Merrick v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., 594 F. Supp. 2d 1168 (D. Nev. 2008) (findings of fact and conclusions of law), summarized with the court’s findings quoted — read the summary.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 4: Eight Insurers Fined $2,075,000 After Ian and Idalia

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 4. 381 words

After Hurricanes Ian and Idalia, Florida’s insurance regulator examined how eight insurers handled the claims. The findings were not close calls. On September 2, 2025, Insurance Commissioner Mike Yaworsky ordered $2,075,000 in penalties.

The market conduct examinations found adjusters who were not properly appointed, claims communications that went unacknowledged, damage estimates sent without the disclosure statement Florida law requires, Homeowners Claims Bill of Rights never delivered, interest owed and unpaid, and claims neither paid nor denied within 90 days. In one examination, the error rate for the missing disclosure statement ran over 60% for Hurricane Ian claims and over 80% for Hurricane Idalia claims.

The eight companies and their fines: American Coastal, $400,000; American Mobile, $400,000; Clear Blue, $400,000; Monarch National, $325,000; Tower Hill Prime, $250,000; TypTap, $150,000; Centauri Specialty, $100,000; Sutton National, $50,000. Two more examinations were still pending when the fines were announced.

Monarch National is the named example. Its consent order, Case No. 401303-25-CO, filed August 28, 2025, carries the $325,000 penalty. The company failed to include the required disclosure statement — the notice telling a homeowner the estimate is not final and may be revised — on 35% of the claims examined.

That disclosure is not a formality. It is the sentence that tells a policyholder the number in front of them is the insurer’s current evaluation, not the last word. Leave it off, and a homeowner reads an estimate as a verdict. The regulator’s exams say that happened, at scale, after two hurricanes.

Eight companies. One regulator. $2,075,000. The exams are the receipt.

Outcome: Settled (consent orders). Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, September 2, 2025: $2,075,000 in penalties against eight insurers — American Coastal, American Mobile, Centauri Specialty, Clear Blue, Monarch National, Sutton National, Tower Hill Prime, and TypTap — following market conduct examinations of claims handling after Hurricanes Ian and Idalia. Two additional examinations were pending.

Source: Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, press release, September 2, 2025 — read the announcement. Monarch National Insurance Company, Consent Order No. 401303-25-CO (filed August 28, 2025) — read the consent order.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 3: The 10% Rate That Shorted 7,871 Claims

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 3. 320 words

Texas law is plain about a late claim: the insurer owes 18% interest a year. There is one exception. If the claim ends up in a lawsuit under Chapter 542A, the rate drops to about 10%. State Farm Lloyds treated the exception as the rule.

Starting September 1, 2017, the company paid the lower, lawsuit-only rate on every late force-of-nature claim — whether or not anyone sued. The Texas Department of Insurance found the practice violated three sections of the Insurance Code: 542.058, 542.060, and 542A.002.

The scale comes from the company’s own count. It took in 316,505 force-of-nature claims between September 1, 2017 and November 8, 2022. Of those, it identified 7,871 claims paid with the wrong interest. On 2,299 of them the shortfall was under $5.99 each — the company paid each of those policyholders $7, more than the maximum owed.

Consent Order No. 2023-7843 came March 10, 2023. State Farm Lloyds consented to the order: $1,434,010.78 in restitution to the shorted policyholders, plus a $350,000 administrative penalty to the state. The order says the company corrected its internal process as of November 8, 2022.

One wrong rate. Six years. Nearly 8,000 policyholders paid less than Texas law required — and the only reason anyone knows is that a complaint reached the regulator, and the regulator did the math. That’s the receipt.

Outcome: Settled (consent order). Texas Department of Insurance Consent Order No. 2023-7843 (March 10, 2023): State Farm Lloyds paid $1,434,010.78 in restitution to policyholders on 7,871 claims paid with incorrect prompt-pay interest, plus a $350,000 administrative penalty. The company consented to the order.

Source: Texas Department of Insurance, Consent Order No. 2023-7843 (March 10, 2023) — read the consent order.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 2: State Farm’s Katrina Fraud Verdict

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 2. 543 words

After Hurricane Katrina, State Farm sold the same homeowner two policies: its own wind policy, and a federal flood policy it administered for the government. Wind damage was State Farm’s bill. Flood damage was the taxpayers’ bill. The Supreme Court later named the incentive plainly: State Farm had reason to classify hurricane damage as flood-related, to limit its own exposure.

Two of State Farm’s own adjusters said that’s what happened. Sisters Cori and Kerri Rigsby worked for a State Farm contractor, walking wrecked homes on the Mississippi Gulf Coast. They said adjusters were instructed to write wind damage up as flood damage — and they took the documents to prove it. In April 2006 they sued under the False Claims Act, on behalf of the United States.

The case went to trial on one house: the North Biloxi home of Thomas and Pamela McIntosh. State Farm paid the McIntoshes the full $250,000 flood limits under the federal policy — and $36,000 for wind, on a policy that provided more than $500,000 in wind coverage. Then it billed the federal flood program $250,000 for damage the jury found was wind.

The proof came from State Farm’s own file. Its engineering firm, Forensic Analysis, concluded the damage was primarily caused by wind. The jury found the McIntosh home sustained no compensable flood damage at all — and that State Farm knowingly presented a false claim to the United States and made a false record to support it.

The verdict came April 8, 2013. The judge ordered State Farm to pay $750,000 — the $250,000 false claim, trebled under the False Claims Act — plus $2.9 million in the Rigsbys’ attorney’s fees and expenses. The Fifth Circuit affirmed. On December 6, 2016, the U.S. Supreme Court affirmed 8–0, rejecting State Farm’s bid to have the case thrown out over a seal violation.

State Farm kept fighting for six more years. On August 19, 2022, it settled: $100 million to the federal government, and the sixteen-year case was dismissed with prejudice. The money went to the government, not to the policyholders whose wind claims had been shifted to flood.

One house. One jury. One false claim for $250,000 — and it took sixteen years and $100 million to close the file. That’s the receipt.

Outcome: Plaintiff won, then settled. Federal jury found State Farm knowingly presented a false claim to the United States (April 8, 2013); $250,000 trebled to $750,000; affirmed by the Fifth Circuit and 8–0 by the U.S. Supreme Court (December 6, 2016). State Farm paid $100 million to the federal government in settlement (August 19, 2022); the case was dismissed with prejudice.

Source: United States ex rel. Rigsby v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 1:06-cv-00433 (S.D. Miss.) — jury verdict April 8, 2013; affirmed, 794 F.3d 457 (5th Cir. 2015); affirmed, State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. United States ex rel. Rigsby, 580 U.S. 7 (2016) — read the Supreme Court opinion. Settlement reported August 25, 2022 — read the report.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 1: State Farm’s Payout-Capping Scheme, Admitted in Court

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 1. 477 words

In 1981, a car crash in Utah left one person dead and another permanently disabled. State Farm’s insured was 100% at fault. The policy limit was $50,000. State Farm refused to pay it. A jury returned a verdict of $185,849. State Farm refused to pay the excess — and told the Campbells to put their house up for sale.

That’s how the Campbells ended up in a bad-faith trial. And that’s where State Farm’s own program came into the record.

At trial, the Campbells introduced evidence of State Farm’s nationwide “Performance, Planning and Review” program — PP&R. The trial court found, in its own words, that the program “has functioned, and continues to function, as an unlawful scheme … to deny benefits owed consumers by paying out less than fair value in order to meet preset, arbitrary payout targets designed to enhance corporate profits.”

The Utah Supreme Court, summarizing the admitted evidence, wrote that “State Farm repeatedly and deliberately deceived and cheated its customers.” Agents changed the contents of files. They lied to customers. The practices were directed at people State Farm believed less likely to object — the poor, minorities, women, the elderly. The company engaged in “deliberate concealment and destruction” of documents. And it instructed its people to use “mad dog defense tactics.”

The jury awarded $2.6 million in compensatory damages and $145 million in punitive damages. The Utah Supreme Court reinstated the $145 million. The U.S. Supreme Court later cut the punitive award to $9,018,780.75 — on due-process grounds, because the amount was excessive. The factual findings about the PP&R scheme were not overturned. The scheme stayed on the record.

Here’s what matters. This wasn’t one adjuster. This wasn’t one bad claim. This was a nationwide program, designed at the top, to pay less than fair value — and to target the people least likely to fight back. The evidence was admitted. A state supreme court put it in its own words. And the company at the center of it is State Farm — the largest home insurer in America, the same company at the center of the Senate’s 2026 inquiry into claims resolved without payment.

They take your premiums. They spend them fighting you. That’s not an accusation. That’s the file. That’s the receipt.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. Jury: $2.6 million compensatory, $145 million punitive (later reduced to $9,018,780.75 on due process; the findings about the scheme were not overturned).

Source: Campbell v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 2001 UT 89 (Utah Sup. Ct.) — read the opinion. U.S. Supreme Court: State Farm v. Campbell, 538 U.S. 408 (2003) — read the opinion.

More from The Files →