The Files, Case 9: The Biased Medical Examiner

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 9. 679 words

Joan Hangarter ran her own chiropractic practice in Berkeley, California, treating 30 to 50 patients a day. In 1989 she bought an “own occupation” disability policy from the Paul Revere Life Insurance Company. If she could no longer do her own job, the policy would pay. By 1997, shoulder, elbow, and wrist pain had left her unable to work. She filed a claim. Paul Revere paid her for eleven months. Then it stopped.

The decision rested on one doctor. Paul Revere hired Dr. Aubrey Swartz as its “independent medical examiner.” The company had used Dr. Swartz nineteen times from 1995 to 2000. In thirteen out of thirteen total-disability cases, he rejected the claim. Before he ever examined Hangarter, an in-house medical consultant who had never examined her either wrote him that there were no objective findings of a disabling injury. At trial, an industry expert testified that letter “bias[ed]” and “predispos[ed]” the doctor. Dr. Swartz called her condition “normal” and said she could see two patients an hour. Her own doctors disagreed: three MRIs showed her condition worsening, and they testified she could not maintain a normal, continuous chiropractic occupation. While a hired colleague covered her practice, Hangarter performed adjustments for only 5 of more than 9,000 patient visits. She sold the practice because she could no longer afford to pay her replacement.

The letter that cut her off was, in the words of the expert who testified at trial, misleading, deceptive, and below industry standards. It said she was “working,” and therefore ineligible — false, because she had already sold her practice. It then denied her residual benefits on the opposite ground: because she had sold her business and “was not working.” It said nothing about recovery or rehabilitation benefits, which she had asked about and been wrongly told she could not have. And it told her the policy was governed by ERISA — which, if true, would have cut off her state-law remedies, including punitive damages. After the termination, the company attached her bank account for insurance premiums until the account was drained, and then cancelled her policy.

The trial showed the machinery behind the letter. Paul Revere had a system for targeting expensive claims — “own occupation” policies held by disabled professionals who had been receiving benefits for months or years — and ran “round table” claim reviews with the goal of achieving a “net termination ratio”: the value of terminated claims compared with new ones. After eleven days of trial, a unanimous jury awarded Hangarter $7,670,849: $5,000,000 in punitive damages, $1,520,849 in past and future unpaid benefits, $400,000 for emotional distress, and $750,000 in attorneys’ fees. On June 25, 2004, the Ninth Circuit affirmed. It held that UnumProvident — Paul Revere’s parent — “engaged in biased and bad faith claims handling and investigation,” and that her own treating physician “was misled by defendant’s systematic claims practices.” The court reversed only a permanent injunction the trial judge had issued under California’s Unfair Competition Act.

An examiner used nineteen times, who rejected the claim thirteen times out of thirteen. A termination letter that said she was working and not working on the same page. A bank account drained for premiums, then a cancelled policy. The jury put a $7,670,849 number on it. A federal appeals court kept it.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. After eleven days of trial, a unanimous federal jury in San Francisco awarded Joan Hangarter $7,670,849 — $5,000,000 punitive damages, $1,520,849 past and future unpaid benefits, $400,000 emotional distress, $750,000 attorneys’ fees (N.D. Cal.). The Ninth Circuit affirmed the denial of judgment as a matter of law and the damages award on June 25, 2004 (373 F.3d 998), reversing only a permanent injunction issued under California’s Unfair Competition Act.

Source: Hangarter v. Provident Life & Accident Insurance Co., 373 F.3d 998 (9th Cir. 2004) — read the opinion.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 8: The First Big Unum Loss

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 8. 434 words

Dr. John Tedesco was an eye surgeon in Florida. In 1992 he bought a disability policy from the Paul Revere Life Insurance Company — about $3,800 a year. The promise was simple: if he could no longer operate, he would still be paid. He paid his premiums. Then Parkinson’s disease and a herniated back left him with hand tremors. He could no longer hold a scalpel steady. In early 1998 he closed his practice.

Paul Revere paid him for five months. Then it stopped. Tedesco sued. The case went to trial in Tampa — nine days of evidence in federal court. Three months before trial, the company paid $265,000 in back benefits. The jury was not persuaded. On May 25, 2001, it found the company had fraudulently terminated his disability benefits and awarded $36.7 million in punitive damages.

The verdict made news. CBS’s “60 Minutes” featured the case, and the trial record became the evidence trove for the Unum cases that followed. But the verdict did not stand as a judgment. Paul Revere moved for a new trial. The two sides went to mediation in March 2002, and the mediator reported the case had been “completely settled.” On the parties’ joint motion, the judge vacated the verdict and the judgment and dismissed the case with prejudice. The settlement amount was never disclosed.

A surgeon who could not hold a scalpel steady bought a policy that promised to pay him if that day came. The company paid for five months, then cut him off. A jury called it fraud and put a $36.7 million number on it. Then the parties settled, the verdict was vacated, and the number went away. The record of what the jury found is still there.

Outcome: Plaintiff won at trial, then settled. A federal jury in Tampa awarded Dr. John Tedesco $36.7 million in punitive damages on May 25, 2001 (M.D. Fla., No. 8:99-cv-2552), finding Paul Revere Life Insurance Company fraudulently terminated his disability benefits. In March 2002 the parties settled; on May 3, 2002, the court vacated the verdict and judgment and dismissed the case with prejudice on the parties’ joint motion. The settlement amount was not disclosed.

Source: Tedesco v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., No. 8:99-cv-2552 (M.D. Fla.) — read the docket. Plaintiff Magazine’s account of the Unum cases — read it.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 7: The Termination Targets

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 7. 542 words

Dr. Randall Chapman was an eye surgeon in Novato, California. For 20 years he performed eye surgery. In 1983 he bought a disability policy from Provident Life & Accident Insurance Company. In 1987 he bought another from The Paul Revere Life Insurance Company — and with it came a “specialty letter,” a written promise that he was insured in his particular specialty as an eye surgeon. He paid his premiums every month for 17 years.

In the late 1990s, Chapman started to develop extreme anxiety about surgery — panic attacks, shaking hands, diarrhea, vomiting, sleepless nights. Surgeries began to go wrong. He took himself off the surgery schedule. His psychiatrist diagnosed a specific phobia — panic in the operating room — and told him to retire from eye surgery. He filed his disability claim.

At trial, which lasted three months, the jury heard how the claim was handled. The claims department read his medical records in a way calculated to produce a denial. The company held a secret “roundtable” meeting about his claim — and destroyed the notes, company policy. It never had him examined by an unbiased physician. It said his condition could be treated, said he was not even an eye surgeon, called him a fraud — and denied his claim to meet monthly and quarterly termination goals. Management called the expected savings reserve “recoveries” — dollar amounts of claims it expected to terminate in the coming months, distributed as targets inside the claims department.

The jury found Chapman totally disabled from his occupation and entitled to disability benefits for the rest of his life: $1,551,301 in benefits, $125,000 for emotional distress, and $30 million in punitive damages. The $31.7 million verdict was the largest in Marin County history — by a factor of three. It was the second-largest verdict in the nation in a UnumProvident case.

Then the trial judge cut it. She reduced the benefits to $1,112,405, the emotional distress to $15,000, and the punitive damages to $5 million. Chapman’s lawyers objected and appealed the reduction. UnumProvident appealed the bad-faith and punitive findings. The verdict came as regulators in California, Georgia and Tennessee were examining the company’s claims practices.

A surgeon paid for 17 years for a promise: if he could no longer operate, he was covered. When his hands shook too much to hold a scalpel, the company called him a fraud. The trial showed the denial was not a judgment call. It was a termination goal.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. Marin County Superior Court, Jan. 23, 2003: a jury awarded Dr. Randall Chapman $31.7 million — $1,551,301 in lifetime disability benefits, $125,000 emotional distress, $30 million punitive damages — finding UnumProvident acted with malice and fraud and denied his claim in bad faith. The trial judge reduced the award to $6.1 million ($1,112,405 benefits, $15,000 emotional distress, $5 million punitive). Both sides appealed.

Source: Chapman v. UnumProvident Corp., No. CV-012323 (Cal. Super. Ct., Marin Co., Jan. 23, 2003) — read the verdict account. The Wall Street Journal’s report, via PLANSPONSOR — read it.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 6: The $60 Million Disability Retrial

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 6. 645 words

G. Clinton Merrick Jr. was a venture capitalist. In 1989 he bought an “own occupation” disability policy from Paul Revere Life Insurance Company — $12,000 a month if he could no longer do his job. In the early 1990s he got sick: fatigue, muscle pain, mental confusion. His doctors said chronic fatigue syndrome and Lyme disease. The Mayo Clinic agreed.

Paul Revere paid his claim from December 1994. Then it stopped. The examiner the company hired could not say whether Merrick could work, and the company’s own file said the records supported “significant impairment.” On December 9, 1996, Paul Revere denied the claim anyway — no “objective medical documentation,” it said, of an inability to work as a venture capitalist.

There was a problem with that demand. There is no objective test for chronic fatigue syndrome. Unum’s own internal studies said so, and the policy never required objective proof. The court later found the company knew all of it — and demanded the proof anyway.

At trial in 2004, the jury heard what the denial was part of. An insurance expert walked through the internal memos: pressure claimants to settle for a fraction, demand objective evidence the policy never required, build a stable of medical examiners who would support denials, have in-house doctors cherry-pick the file for reasons to deny, hold round-table meetings to triage the most expensive claims. The jury awarded Merrick $1,147,355 in unpaid benefits and $500,000 for emotional distress — and $10 million in punitive damages.

The Ninth Circuit threw out the punitive award in 2007 — not because the conduct was excused, but because the jury had not been given a required limiting instruction. It ordered a retrial on punitive damages only. In June 2008, the second jury came back with $60 million: $24 million against Paul Revere, $36 million against UnumProvident.

Then the trial judge put the findings in writing. In Merrick v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., 594 F. Supp. 2d 1168, the court found “more than ample evidence” that the companies were “engaged in a scheme to deny their disabled policyholders’ claims dating back to the early 1990s.” The conduct was “not the result of accident or inadvertence,” the court wrote, but “part of a widespread corporate plan or scheme designed to augment corporate profits through wrongful conduct targeted at disabled policyholders.” The court found the terminations were saving the companies over $130 million a quarter by 1996. It let the $24 million award stand and cut UnumProvident’s $36 million to $26,394,765.39 — a 9-to-1 ratio. The case settled in 2010.

A man bought a policy that promised to pay if he could not do his job. He could not do his job. The company had the paper that said so. It denied him anyway — and the paper trail showed it was not a mistake. It was the plan.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. 2004 jury: $1,147,355 in unpaid benefits, $500,000 emotional distress, $10 million punitive damages. The Ninth Circuit (500 F.3d 1007, 2007) ordered a retrial on punitive damages only. June 2008 retrial jury: $60 million punitive ($24 million Paul Revere, $36 million UnumProvident); the court let the $24 million stand and cut UnumProvident’s share to $26,394,765.39. Settled out of court, 2010.

Source: Merrick v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., 500 F.3d 1007 (9th Cir. 2007) — read the opinion. Judgment, July 3, 2008 ($24 million Paul Revere, $36 million UnumProvident) — read the judgment. Merrick v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., 594 F. Supp. 2d 1168 (D. Nev. 2008) (findings of fact and conclusions of law), summarized with the court’s findings quoted — read the summary.

More from The Files →