The Files, Case 6: The $60 Million Disability Retrial

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 6. 645 words

G. Clinton Merrick Jr. was a venture capitalist. In 1989 he bought an “own occupation” disability policy from Paul Revere Life Insurance Company — $12,000 a month if he could no longer do his job. In the early 1990s he got sick: fatigue, muscle pain, mental confusion. His doctors said chronic fatigue syndrome and Lyme disease. The Mayo Clinic agreed.

Paul Revere paid his claim from December 1994. Then it stopped. The examiner the company hired could not say whether Merrick could work, and the company’s own file said the records supported “significant impairment.” On December 9, 1996, Paul Revere denied the claim anyway — no “objective medical documentation,” it said, of an inability to work as a venture capitalist.

There was a problem with that demand. There is no objective test for chronic fatigue syndrome. Unum’s own internal studies said so, and the policy never required objective proof. The court later found the company knew all of it — and demanded the proof anyway.

At trial in 2004, the jury heard what the denial was part of. An insurance expert walked through the internal memos: pressure claimants to settle for a fraction, demand objective evidence the policy never required, build a stable of medical examiners who would support denials, have in-house doctors cherry-pick the file for reasons to deny, hold round-table meetings to triage the most expensive claims. The jury awarded Merrick $1,147,355 in unpaid benefits and $500,000 for emotional distress — and $10 million in punitive damages.

The Ninth Circuit threw out the punitive award in 2007 — not because the conduct was excused, but because the jury had not been given a required limiting instruction. It ordered a retrial on punitive damages only. In June 2008, the second jury came back with $60 million: $24 million against Paul Revere, $36 million against UnumProvident.

Then the trial judge put the findings in writing. In Merrick v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., 594 F. Supp. 2d 1168, the court found “more than ample evidence” that the companies were “engaged in a scheme to deny their disabled policyholders’ claims dating back to the early 1990s.” The conduct was “not the result of accident or inadvertence,” the court wrote, but “part of a widespread corporate plan or scheme designed to augment corporate profits through wrongful conduct targeted at disabled policyholders.” The court found the terminations were saving the companies over $130 million a quarter by 1996. It let the $24 million award stand and cut UnumProvident’s $36 million to $26,394,765.39 — a 9-to-1 ratio. The case settled in 2010.

A man bought a policy that promised to pay if he could not do his job. He could not do his job. The company had the paper that said so. It denied him anyway — and the paper trail showed it was not a mistake. It was the plan.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. 2004 jury: $1,147,355 in unpaid benefits, $500,000 emotional distress, $10 million punitive damages. The Ninth Circuit (500 F.3d 1007, 2007) ordered a retrial on punitive damages only. June 2008 retrial jury: $60 million punitive ($24 million Paul Revere, $36 million UnumProvident); the court let the $24 million stand and cut UnumProvident’s share to $26,394,765.39. Settled out of court, 2010.

Source: Merrick v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., 500 F.3d 1007 (9th Cir. 2007) — read the opinion. Judgment, July 3, 2008 ($24 million Paul Revere, $36 million UnumProvident) — read the judgment. Merrick v. Paul Revere Life Insurance Co., 594 F. Supp. 2d 1168 (D. Nev. 2008) (findings of fact and conclusions of law), summarized with the court’s findings quoted — read the summary.

More from The Files →

Leave a Reply