The Files, Case 12: The Case That Created Bad-Faith Law

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 12. 681 words

In 1962, Michael Egan, a roofer, bought a health and disability policy from Mutual of Omaha. It promised $200 a month for life if he became totally disabled by an accidental injury. Between 1963 and 1970 he claimed and received benefits for three separate back injuries. In May 1970, working as a roofer, he hurt his back again — a fourth claim, for an accidental injury on the job.

Mutual paid three months of accident benefits. Then its adjusters went to work. They reviewed workers’ compensation records and hospital files. They read letters from Egan’s surgeon, who said his history was “consistent with a man with probable discogenic disease with multiple aggravations over the last several years, finally culminating in a specific incident a little over seven months ago.” They never called Egan’s doctors. Trial testimony established that an adjuster would ordinarily have done so.

On the basis of the paper alone, Mutual reclassified Egan’s injury as a sickness — a nonconfining illness, capped at three months of benefits. In May 1971, an adjuster visited Egan at home, told him he suffered from an illness, not an injury, and handed him a check for medical costs and three months’ maximum disability payments. Egan did not cash it. He testified the adjuster offered him a larger check if he would surrender his policy. He refused. He wrote to the adjuster about the reclassification and got no answer. Meanwhile his file, a Mutual manager testified, may have “fallen … into a crack.” In July 1972, at Egan’s request, the California Department of Insurance asked Mutual to review the file. Whatever Mutual answered was never produced at trial.

Egan sued in 1973. The trial court ruled as a matter of law that Mutual’s failure to have Egan examined by a doctor of its choice, or to consult his treating physicians, violated the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. The jury awarded $45,600 in general damages and $78,000 for emotional distress against Mutual — and $5 million in punitive damages.

On August 14, 1979, the California Supreme Court affirmed the compensatory award and the breach. An insurer, the court held, “cannot reasonably and in good faith deny payments to its insured without thoroughly investigating the foundation for its denial.” It is “essential that an insurer fully inquire into possible bases that might support the insured’s claim.” That sentence is the foundation of modern bad-faith law: the duty to investigate before denying.

But the court cut the $5 million punitive award — more than 40 times the $123,600 in compensatory damages, and two and a half months of Mutual’s entire 1973 net income. Viewing the record as a whole, the court said, the award “must be deemed the result of passion and prejudice on the part of the jurors and excessive as a matter of law.” It also reversed the judgments against the two individual adjusters: as agents, they were not parties to the insurance contract and were not subject to the implied covenant. Egan kept his $123,600. The $5 million was gone.

A roofer who hurt his back on the job. An insurer that read the paper, never called the doctors, and called an injury a sickness. The court that said investigate first — and that even a company that breaks faith does not owe $5 million for it. That is the case that created bad-faith law, caveat included.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. The California Supreme Court, 24 Cal.3d 809 (Aug. 14, 1979), affirmed the jury’s finding that Mutual of Omaha breached the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and affirmed the $45,600 in disability benefits and $78,000 for emotional distress. It reversed the $5 million punitive award as excessive and reversed the judgments against the two individual adjusters.

Source: Egan v. Mutual of Omaha Ins. Co., 24 Cal.3d 809 (1979) — read the opinion.

More from The Files →