By Insurance Justice Staff
The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.
This is Case 13. 476 words
In May 2013, five states settled with Cigna. California, Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, and Pennsylvania had spent years examining how three Cigna companies — Cigna Health and Life, Connecticut General Life, and the Life Insurance Company of North America — handled group long-term disability claims. The examinations began in 2009. What they found, in the words of Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner Michael Consedine, was that the companies “were lax and not using available information to appropriately process disability income insurance claims.”
“Not using available information” is the polite version. These were disability claims — people too sick or hurt to work, asking the insurer to pay what the policy promised. The regulators found the companies deciding those claims without using the information in front of them. California had been here before: it fined LINA $600,000 in 2006 over disability claims-handling violations, and reopened that examination as part of this one.
The settlement, signed May 13, 2013, put numbers on it. The companies paid $1,675,000 in fines and fees to the five states — $500,000 to California, $250,000 to Massachusetts, $175,000 to Maine — and set aside $77 million for the policyholders: $48 million in reserves in case additional benefits were owed, and $29 million more for claims still open. They had to re-examine every long-term disability claim denied or terminated in 2009 and 2010 — in California, back to 2008 — under new procedures, and submit to two years of monitoring by the five states, with a re-examination at the end.
Cigna denied wrongdoing. This was not a jury verdict; it was a regulatory settlement built on the states’ examination findings. But the remedy tells the story: $77 million put aside for people whose claims were not handled properly, thousands of denied claims reopened, and new procedures the companies had to adopt — giving greater weight to Social Security disability approvals, and taking every reasonable step to verify a claimant’s condition. The kind of steps the examination found missing.
Five states. One examination finding. Seventy-seven million dollars. The receipts are the settlement agreement itself — signed, filed, and paid.
Outcome: Settled (regulatory settlement agreement). On May 13, 2013, Cigna Health and Life Insurance Company, Connecticut General Life Insurance Company, and the Life Insurance Company of North America settled with the insurance departments of California, Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, and Pennsylvania. The companies paid $1,675,000 in fines and fees and set aside $77 million for payments to policyholders whose claims were not handled properly. The companies denied wrongdoing.
Source: California Department of Insurance press release, May 24, 2013 — read the announcement. Regulatory Settlement Agreement, May 13, 2013 — read the agreement.

