The Files, Case 10: The Wrong Zip Code

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 10. 726 words

On March 29, 1990, Marion Taylor’s car collided with a car owned by Barry Berges. The crash killed Marion Taylor and seriously injured her young daughter, who was riding with her. Infinity Insurance Company insured Berges’s car. The policy limits were $10,000 per person and $20,000 per accident. By April 30, Infinity’s own investigator had concluded that the driver of Berges’s car had been intoxicated, had crossed the center line, and was “100%” at fault. The daughter’s medical bills were already over $30,000.

On May 2, the widower walked into Infinity’s office and hand-delivered a letter. He offered to settle both claims for the $20,000 limits: his wife’s wrongful-death claim for $10,000, his daughter’s injury claim for $10,000. He needed the money paid by May 27 for the estate and by June 1 for his daughter. He had missed a great deal of work. Doctor bills were coming almost every day. His daughter was hurt very bad, and he expected many more bills, especially because she had scarring from the surgery. He stapled some of the bills to the letter.

Infinity never told Berges the offer existed. On May 11, adjuster Robert Fryer called Taylor and said Infinity would pay the limits and arrange the court approval the minor’s claim needed. Fryer said he would meet with Infinity’s attorney on May 14 to work out the details. The meeting never happened. Fryer never told Taylor. On May 16, Infinity hired attorney Kevin Korth to seek the court’s approval. Korth’s own May 23 memorandum said Infinity was operating under a “time demand.” Korth finally wrote to Taylor on May 24 — thirteen days after Fryer’s promise, three days before the first deadline.

The letter used the wrong zip code. It did not reach Taylor until June 20, after both deadlines had expired. Taylor had heard nothing from Infinity since May 11. On June 11, his lawyer wrote Infinity that the May 2 offer was revoked. The wrongful-death and personal-injury suits followed. The jury awarded $911,400 for Marion Taylor’s death and $500,000 for her daughter’s injuries. Berges, who had bought a $20,000 policy, now faced a judgment nearly a hundred times that.

Almost a month after the deadlines expired, Infinity told Berges — for the first time — that he faced an excess judgment and could hire his own lawyer. The letter’s postscript said Taylor “refused to settle.” It did not mention the deadlines. It did not mention the terms of the offer. It did not mention that Infinity had never told Berges the offer existed.

Berges sued Infinity for bad faith. A jury found Infinity acted in bad faith in failing to settle the Taylor claims within the limits and in failing to advise its insured about the offer. The trial court entered an amended final judgment of $1,893,066.41 — the excess judgment plus accrued interest. The Second District Court of Appeal reversed, saying the offer was invalid because Taylor had not obtained court approval first. On November 18, 2004, the Florida Supreme Court quashed that decision and ordered the judgment reinstated, holding the jury’s bad-faith finding “was supported by competent, substantial evidence.” Court approval, the court said, is not a prerequisite to a valid settlement offer for a minor.

A $20,000 policy. A handwritten offer, delivered by hand. A promise on the phone, a meeting that never happened, a letter sent to the wrong zip code. The Florida Supreme Court put the $1,893,066.41 judgment back on the books.

Outcome: Plaintiff won. A jury found Infinity Insurance Company acted in bad faith toward its insured, Barry Berges, in failing to settle the Taylor claims within the $20,000 policy limits and in failing to advise Berges of the settlement offer; the trial court entered an amended final judgment of $1,893,066.41. The Second District Court of Appeal reversed, but the Florida Supreme Court quashed that decision on November 18, 2004 (896 So. 2d 665) and remanded for reinstatement of the final judgment, holding the bad-faith finding “was supported by competent, substantial evidence.”

Source: Berges v. Infinity Insurance Co., 896 So. 2d 665 (Fla. 2004) — read the opinion.

More from The Files →