The Files, Case 2: State Farm’s Katrina Fraud Verdict

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 2. 543 words

After Hurricane Katrina, State Farm sold the same homeowner two policies: its own wind policy, and a federal flood policy it administered for the government. Wind damage was State Farm’s bill. Flood damage was the taxpayers’ bill. The Supreme Court later named the incentive plainly: State Farm had reason to classify hurricane damage as flood-related, to limit its own exposure.

Two of State Farm’s own adjusters said that’s what happened. Sisters Cori and Kerri Rigsby worked for a State Farm contractor, walking wrecked homes on the Mississippi Gulf Coast. They said adjusters were instructed to write wind damage up as flood damage — and they took the documents to prove it. In April 2006 they sued under the False Claims Act, on behalf of the United States.

The case went to trial on one house: the North Biloxi home of Thomas and Pamela McIntosh. State Farm paid the McIntoshes the full $250,000 flood limits under the federal policy — and $36,000 for wind, on a policy that provided more than $500,000 in wind coverage. Then it billed the federal flood program $250,000 for damage the jury found was wind.

The proof came from State Farm’s own file. Its engineering firm, Forensic Analysis, concluded the damage was primarily caused by wind. The jury found the McIntosh home sustained no compensable flood damage at all — and that State Farm knowingly presented a false claim to the United States and made a false record to support it.

The verdict came April 8, 2013. The judge ordered State Farm to pay $750,000 — the $250,000 false claim, trebled under the False Claims Act — plus $2.9 million in the Rigsbys’ attorney’s fees and expenses. The Fifth Circuit affirmed. On December 6, 2016, the U.S. Supreme Court affirmed 8–0, rejecting State Farm’s bid to have the case thrown out over a seal violation.

State Farm kept fighting for six more years. On August 19, 2022, it settled: $100 million to the federal government, and the sixteen-year case was dismissed with prejudice. The money went to the government, not to the policyholders whose wind claims had been shifted to flood.

One house. One jury. One false claim for $250,000 — and it took sixteen years and $100 million to close the file. That’s the receipt.

Outcome: Plaintiff won, then settled. Federal jury found State Farm knowingly presented a false claim to the United States (April 8, 2013); $250,000 trebled to $750,000; affirmed by the Fifth Circuit and 8–0 by the U.S. Supreme Court (December 6, 2016). State Farm paid $100 million to the federal government in settlement (August 19, 2022); the case was dismissed with prejudice.

Source: United States ex rel. Rigsby v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 1:06-cv-00433 (S.D. Miss.) — jury verdict April 8, 2013; affirmed, 794 F.3d 457 (5th Cir. 2015); affirmed, State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. United States ex rel. Rigsby, 580 U.S. 7 (2016) — read the Supreme Court opinion. Settlement reported August 25, 2022 — read the report.

More from The Files →