The Files, Case 16: A Decade of Shorting 88,000 Members — $41 Million

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 16. 414 words

Health Net of New Jersey underpaid its own members’ out-of-network claims for a decade — medical claims from 1996, dental, mental health and chiropractic claims from 1999. When the state caught the problem in 2002, Health Net said it ran only from July 2001 to October 2002. The state’s exam found otherwise.

The New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance first learned of it in 2002, from a consumer complaint. That December it settled with Health Net for more than $800,000 in restitution to more than 4,700 members. In 2005, the Department learned the underpayments had begun earlier than Health Net had disclosed. A 21-month examination followed, concluding in May 2008.

The findings, in the Department’s own words: Health Net “systemically under-reimbursed certain types of claims,” affecting approximately 88,000 members; “failed to initially disclose to the Department the true extent of under-reimbursements”; “failed to initially properly remediate under-reimbursements”; and “improperly denied certain claims for lack of pre-authorization.” The company’s vendors for chiropractic and mental health services made underpayments too.

The order: $14 million in unpaid claims, $12 million in interest, $2 million in examination fees, and a record $13 million fine — $41 million in all. The $26 million in restitution and interest had already been paid to the 88,000 members. Commissioner Steven M. Goldman put it plainly: “Health Net dramatically underpaid claims to New Jerseyans to reimburse them for out-of-network health care services.” Health Net waived its right to a hearing, acknowledged its responsibility to comply with the law, and overhauled the systems that led to the underpayments. The Department said it would keep monitoring the company.

Outcome: Settled (consent order). New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance, Consent Order No. E08-71, August 26, 2008: Health Net of New Jersey paid $14 million in unpaid claims, $12 million in interest, $2 million in examination fees, and a record $13 million fine — $41 million in total — and had already paid $26 million in restitution and interest to approximately 88,000 members. Health Net waived its right to a hearing and cooperated with the investigation.

Source: New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance press release, August 26, 2008 — read the release. DOBI 2008 enforcement activity listing, Consent Order No. E08-71 — read the listing.

More from The Files →

The Files, Case 15: 1,600 Policies Cancelled — $35.5 Million Saved

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 15. 611 words

Health Net of California cancelled about 1,600 individual health policies between 2000 and 2006 — after the policyholders got sick and the bills started arriving. The company’s own documents, produced at an arbitration hearing, showed it avoided $35.5 million in medical expenses by doing it. The practice has a name: rescission. Sell the policy, collect the premiums, and cancel it when the claim comes in.

The documents showed why it kept happening. Health Net set cancellation targets and paid bonuses tied in part to how many policies its senior analyst revoked. In 2002, her goal was 180 cancellations. She cancelled 275. She received more than $20,000 in bonuses based in part on meeting or exceeding those targets. California law forbids tying a claims reviewer’s pay to claims decisions. Health Net’s lawyer argued the law did not apply — she was an underwriter, not a claims reviewer.

Patsy Bates, a 51-year-old hair salon owner from Gardena, had her coverage rescinded while she was receiving chemotherapy for breast cancer. She was left with $129,000 in medical bills and had to stop her chemotherapy until a charity helped her pay. In February 2008, arbitrator Sam Cianchetti — a retired Los Angeles County Superior Court judge — awarded her more than $9 million, $8.4 million of it punitive. He called Health Net’s conduct “egregious” and wrote that the company “was primarily concerned with and considered its own financial interests and gave little, if any, consideration and concern for the interests of the insured.” On the bonuses, he wrote: “It’s difficult to imagine a policy more reprehensible than tying bonuses to encourage the rescission of health insurance that keeps the public well and alive.”

The regulators came next. In June 2008, the Department of Managed Health Care settled: a $300,000 fine and coverage offered to 85 HMO members. In September 2008, the California Department of Insurance settled: a $3.6 million fine, about $14.2 million in medical bills, and 926 policyholders reinstated — new policies with no underwriting requirement and no exclusions for preexisting conditions. Health Net admitted no wrongdoing in either settlement, but agreed to change its business practices.

In February 2009, the Los Angeles City Attorney’s class action settled too: up to $14 million to 800 former policyholders whose coverage was dropped after they submitted substantial medical bills — up to $218,000 each — plus a $2 million fine to the city attorney and $500,000 to charities. All told, Health Net agreed to pay more than $40 million across the regulatory actions and the litigation. The $35.5 million it saved by cancelling 1,600 sick people’s policies was the math that made the whole thing work — until the receipts came out.

Outcome: Settled (regulatory settlements + class action). June 2008: Health Net settled with the California Department of Managed Health Care — a $300,000 fine and coverage offered to 85 HMO members. September 2008: Health Net settled with the California Department of Insurance — a $3.6 million fine, about $14.2 million in medical bills, and 926 policyholders reinstated. February 2009: the Los Angeles City Attorney class action settled — up to $14 million to 800 former policyholders (up to $218,000 each), a $2 million fine, and $500,000 in charitable contributions. More than $40 million in total. Health Net did not admit wrongdoing.

Source: California Department of Insurance–Health Net settlement, September 2008 — read the report. Los Angeles City Attorney settlement, February 2009 — read the report.

More from The Files →