The Files, Case 17: The Exam That Found 1 in 4 Payments Late

Insurance Justice The Files

By Insurance Justice Staff

The Files are original Insurance Justice investigations built only on admitted evidence — court records, agency findings, consent orders. We have the receipts.

This is Case 17. 446 words

Texas regulators examined Anchor General Insurance Company’s private passenger auto business for the year 2022. They sampled 102 claim payments. In one of every four — 26 of 102 — the company failed to give the claimant the required Notice of Rights Regarding Repair of Motor Vehicle, or gave it late. In 12 of 102, it failed to pay the claim by the fifth business day after notice of payment. In 9 of 102, it made no good-faith attempt at a prompt, fair and equitable settlement when liability was reasonably clear.

The exam found more. In 13 of 102 payments, the company never notified the insured in writing that the claim had been settled within 30 days. In 3 of 102, it had no reasonable standards for promptly investigating a claim. And in 17 of 25 total-loss claims reviewed — 68 percent — Anchor General never applied for the appropriate title.

It was not only claims. In 43 of 100 policies sampled, the agent named on the declarations page was not appointed to issue or service policies. In one, the agent was not licensed to sell insurance in Texas at all. In 98 of 100 policies, the notice telling policyholders where to call with complaints was not displayed where Texas law requires it — on the first, second or third page of the policy.

The order: a $130,000 administrative penalty. Anchor General accepted the final examination report and submitted a corrective action plan on April 25, 2025 — the same day it accepted the report. The company said its claims system now generates the repair-rights notice automatically at the start of every claim, and that all licensed adjusters would take compliance training on payment timelines, prompt investigation and good-faith settlement.

Outcome: Settled (consent order). Texas Department of Insurance, Consent Order No. 2025-9603, November 17, 2025 (TDI Enforcement File No. 36973): Anchor General Insurance Company agreed to pay a $130,000 administrative penalty after a targeted market-conduct examination of its 2022 private passenger auto business found the company failed to give required repair-rights notices in 25 percent of sampled claim payments, failed to pay 12 percent of claims within five business days, and made no good-faith settlement attempt in 9 percent of cases where liability was reasonably clear. Anchor General accepted the examination report and submitted a corrective action plan on April 25, 2025.

Source: Texas Department of Insurance, Consent Order No. 2025-9603 (November 17, 2025) — read the order.

More from The Files →