Most-Sued Insurers

Insurance Justice · Data

The Most-Sued Insurers

Lawsuits per year — the insurers we can count from public data.

Snapshot: 11 November 2026

Lawsuits per year — Florida counts where published, federal-only otherwise. Gold badges show expected new lawsuits in the next 7 days.*

1
Citizens Property Insurance
FL · 2023
9,716
+187*
2
Universal Property & Casualty
FL · 2023
5,483
+105*
3
State Farm Fire & Casualty
Fed · avg
1,944
+37*
4
State Farm Mutual Automobile
Fed · avg
713
+14*
5
Allstate Vehicle & Property
Fed · avg
456
+9*
6
Safeco
Fed · avg
176
+3*
7
Scottsdale
Fed · avg
171
+3*
8
Liberty Mutual
Fed · avg
166
+3*
9
GeoVera
Fed · avg
137
+3*
10
Lexington
Fed · avg
117
+2*
11
Progressive
Lawsuit count not publicly available
12
GEICO
Lawsuit count not publicly available
13
Travelers
Lawsuit count not publicly available
02,5005,0007,50010,000

* This isn’t a numerical ranking of every insurer. It’s a list based on available data — only the companies with publicly available counts, ranked by the per-year rates we have.

Addendum — entries 11–13: Progressive, GEICO, and Travelers are listed without numbers. Their lawsuit counts are not publicly available, so they can’t be ranked against the counts above.

* Projection — “Next week” totals are projected from each company’s per-year rate of filings: the annual count divided across 52 weeks. Projected lawsuits have not been filed yet.

Next 7 Days*

Citizens Property Insurance187*
Universal Property & Casualty105*
State Farm Fire & Casualty37*
State Farm Mutual Automobile14*

* Projection — new lawsuits expected in the next 7 days, at each company’s current pace. To be finalized upon further review.

Florida — A Closer Look

One state, broken out as an example — Florida publishes near-complete data, so it’s the state we can analyze most closely.

Florida’s share of all U.S. homeowners lawsuits

Of every homeowners lawsuit filed in America, the share filed in Florida — by year.

202079%
202372%
202541%

Lawsuits served in Florida — by company

2022   2023

Citizens Property Insurance12,234 → 9,716
Universal Property & Casualty10,314 → 5,483
State Farm Florida4,787 → 3,918

How often Floridians sue

143

per 1,000 unpaid claims — Florida, 2025

vs.
11

per 1,000 — the rest of the U.S.

Method

How we count: lawsuits per year, one rate per company, from published public counts — Florida counts where a state publishes them (Florida, 2023), federal-court counts otherwise (multi-year averages where the source reports a range of years). The list covers only the insurers we can count from public data; it is not a complete ranking of every insurer, and companies whose counts are not publicly available are listed without numbers. *Projections are next-7-days estimates from each company’s per-year pace — annual rate ÷ 52 weeks — to be finalized upon further review. Sources: Lex Machina Insurance Litigation Reports; Florida DFS / OIR; Florida OIR stability reports via Weiss Ratings.

Insurance Justice · Most-Sued Insurers Tracker · 11 November 2026.